*could it be that*

[Daisy55]

the judges are rigging American Idol?

Also why haven't they said anything bad about Ruben? few times I heard him sing and it was not good at times. Well they said he sings about the same every week. but they haven't talked bad to him like the others..

I think the judges are scared to said something bad cause Ruben might go and sit on Simon and break his bones.. Don't make the teddy bear mad oh no, dn't do that....

Also how is Josh staying on. He was horrible couple of times... (um the war is dying off now, so it's safe to let him go home now)


I miss Ricky and Vanessa... I think Vanessa will have a sing career anyway or something.. or she might be a full figured clothing model... or nude model lol

Carmen doesn't know her vocie too well, she has a good voice but she can't seem to find the golden touch to it. one minute it sounds good then it it sound awful... she needs a music teacher to teach her how to sing better...

Kimberly Locke is great, but it's hard to see her being a pop star..

Clay is great and I can see him being a pop star singing strong love ballads.. but him dancing nope... I can see him on top of a mountain singing his heart out... Kinda like Josh Groben but less voice but more popish


and that other girl, is will be known as that other girl who didn't get to have a change to be good enough. she is good but she is over looked at times.. I can see her having a career after.. But I see her in a group not a solo artist..

[jonm011]

WHY DOES IT MATTER?

1.we all know american idol is rigged, wheres the proof that it's fair? they dont show us the counts.

2.the winner is gonna be a 1nehitwonder anyway! i thank god that kelly was able to get her foot in the door, and then was able to enter the room, but i dont think the winner of american idol 2 will have the same sucess. and even if s/he does, american idol winners from the upcmoming 3rd and 4th seasons are definetly not gonna last.

im jus gonna find it funny when the 3rd and 4th season's top10 go on tour, and no1 goes to see it...hahaha...lol

if it was up to me, ruben would of been gone a long time ago. and so would of clay. i would of made kimberly caldwell win...she deserves it the most. :D

[UpSiDeDoWn]

ehhh.......

[Diva4230]

Kim Caldwell has a nice tone to her voice, but she can't do too much with it.. I'm glad she got as far as she did, but I knew she wouldn't be the winner..