Overrated/Underrated

[grace701]

I got this from an HP message board I go to. Thought it'd be fun to have here. Just add on......

Underrated: Tony Lucca
Overrated: J. Lo

[Tiki]

Underrated: Tony Lucca
Overrated: Beyonce'

[Katlin]

Underrated: Justin
Overrated: Beyonce

[Trinity3]

Underrated: Justin
Overrated: Cameron Diaz

Reason: "Justin is like your g/f's snotty little brother who's always trying to get a look at you." (I may not have gotten that quote exactly right, my mouth was dropping to the floor at the time.)

[giggles602]

underrated: Phil Vassar

overrated: Beyonce, Britney

[Just4ashley21]

Originally posted by Trinity3
Underrated: Justin
Overrated: Cameron Diaz

Reason: "Justin is like your g/f's snotty little brother who's always trying to get a look at you." (I may not have gotten that quote exactly right, my mouth was dropping to the floor at the time.)

who said that? and where did it come from??? how did i miss that?

[Trinity3]

It was on that 101 Hottest Couples thing on E! I was watching it last night, and they had people commenting on the couples. This one woman said that and I couldn't believe it! I have heard Justin get dissed before, but man this wasn't tactful at all!!!

[grace701]

Originally posted by mousiemel
You know what... I almost answered this. Then realized it would be a very bad idea.

But I will say JC is underrated by far.

I think I know where you're getting.

Underrated: Burger King's Chicken Sandwich
Overrated: McD's Chicken Nuggets :p

Underrated: R&B
Overrated: Rap/Hip-Hop/Pop

[Tiki]

I *think* I do too. So you can go ahead and share. :p

[Katlin]

Katlin thinks she knows, but in all reality, she's probably way wrong. :tongue:

[grace701]

Well Tiki if a fight breaks out you started it! :p

Overrated: Justin
Underrated: JC

NOW....don't think I'm being mean. I know JC hasn't come out with a record or anything, but Justin is just all over the place. I still love him. :love: I just love JC more! :love: :love:

[grace701]

Underrated: Harry Potter
Overrated: Harry Potter....:D

[grace701]

Originally posted by mousiemel
LOL! Someone who dared say it!

Well as my sig below says....I'm feeling a bit rebellious...;)

[Tiki]

I disagree. That is all.

[grace701]

I'm sorry Tiki, if you got mad. :(

[Tiki]

I'm not mad, everybody is entitled to their opinions. I just disagree.

[JustifiedFan]

Overrated: BEYONCE, Britney, LIzzy Mcguire (can't think of her real name)

Underrated: CHRISTINA that girl can sing!!

[Tiki]

Right Mel. :p

Tosh: Christina is definitely underrated.

[pinky]

Originally posted by JustifiedFan
Overrated: LIzzy Mcguire (can't think of her real name) That would be Hilary I'd-like-to-giver-her-a-kick-in-the Duff! :p

[JustifiedFan]

yeah I don't like her...

Overrated : *24 star elisha cuthbert :(

[Katlin]

Overrated: Vanilla Coke
Underrated: Root beer! :D

[grace701]

originally posted by Tiki
I'm not mad, everybody is entitled to their opinions. I just disagree.

*sigh* Good :)

I don't watch 24, so for me Elisha Cuthbert is underrated. Isn't she dating someone younger than her?

[KT9484]

Overrated: J-Lo, Beyonce, Britney, and Justin
Underrated: Christina, Nick, Stacie

[Tiki]

Originally posted by grace701
*sigh* Good :)

I don't watch 24, so for me Elisha Cuthbert is underrated. Isn't she dating someone younger than her?

Elisha is dating Trace.

[Katlin]

Originally posted by Tiki
Elisha is dating Trace.

I was going to comment on that. But then I thought that I could be wrong and I would feel dumb in front of you Trace experts. ;)

[Tiki]

Yep, yep. They've been dating since around June.

[Terrence Jamal]

Underrated: Whitney's last album 'Just Whitney'

Overrated: All the negative news about her recently. Everytime she trips, sneezes, coughs, blinks too hard it's because of drugs... (please) :evil:

[MafHoney]

Underrated: Yeah Yeah Yeah's (duh :p)
Overrated: Britney, J-Lo

[pinky junior]

Underrated: John Mayer
Overrated: 50 Cent

[Sunfire]

Originally posted by grace701
I'm sorry Tiki, if you got mad. :(

Girl don't ever be sorry for your opinions! Who cares what others think!!!



Underrated: Christina Aguilera
Overrated: Britney Spears

[Sweet*n*Sexsi]

Underrated: The Calling
Overrated: Coldplay

[nmpv4176]

Underrated: Tamia, Angie Stone, Vivian Green
Overrated: Fred Durst, Jeremy Shockley, Kid Rock, Jared of the "Subway" commercials, those silly, eponomous Geico auto insurance commercials, that geeky "Can You Hear Me Now?....Good" pitchman of the Verizon wireless commercials

[princessKAT]

Underrated: Lucy Woodward
Overrated: Avril Lavigne

[grace701]

Originally posted by nmpv4176
Underrated: Tamia, Angie Stone, Vivian Green
Overrated: Fred Durst, Jeremy Shockley, Kid Rock, Jared of the "Subway" commercials, those silly, eponomous Geico auto insurance commercials, that geeky "Can You Hear Me Now?....Good" pitchman of the Verizon wireless commercials

LOL...That was tooo funny!

Underrated: Jill Scott
Overrated: Avril Lavigne

I know different genres, but for some reason I could't think of anyone else.

[Sweet*n*Sexsi]

Underrated: Simple Plan & Beyonce's cd (it's sooo awesome!!)
Overrated: Michelle Branch

[BrianWilly]

Underrated: BBMak(:cry:!), Jason Mraz, Monica, Stephen Lynch, anything Buffy-related:angel:, but particularly Alyson Hannigan...and loads, loads more.

Overrated: Ashton Kutcher and every reality television show out there.

[Yezdnil]

Overrated: Avril Lavigne, Good Charlotte, Evanesence, Beyonce.

Underrated: Josh Groban, Liz Phair, Dido, Michael Buble, Counting Crows

[Sweet*n*Sexsi]

Originally posted by BrianWilly
Overrated: Ashton Kutcher and every reality television show out there.

^I totally agree with that :D

[pinky]

Originally posted by Sweet*n*Sexsi
Underrated: Simple Plan & Beyonce's cd (it's sooo awesome!!)
Overrated: Michelle Branch Odd....I was thinking the opposite on Beyonce and Michelle Branch!

[Sweet*n*Sexsi]

^:D I know a lot of people say Beyonce is overrated (I don't really agree with that but that's ok :p) but her cd didn't get that much hype..she did, but not her cd..that's why I specified her cd and not her ;)

And with Michelle Branch, I just could never stand her so I guess that's why she seems overrated to me :p

[Salar_ny]

Originally posted by KT9484
Overrated: J-Lo, Beyonce, Britney, and Justin
Underrated: Christina, Nick, Stacie


I think Nick Lachey is underrated too, lol. ;)

When I think of overrated and underrated I think of acts that have a either a lot or a lack of critical hype, not popularity so much. That certainly eliminates the likes of Britney and J. Lo. from the former and Christina from the latter IMO. I also believe that Justin is merely getting the due he deserves, whether those who can't stand him like it or not.
My picks:

Overrated: The White Stripes, The Strokes
Underrated: Jewel and (what the hell) JC