Is Roger Federer the best? Yes? No? Why?

[pranksternicky]

Do you think Roger Federer is the best tennis player to play the game? If so, why? I wanna hear your opinions =)

[db44]

No. He's not as hot as Maria Sharapova. :p

[pranksternicky]

idiot db44;)

[pinky]

Not today, he isn't.

And you're stating the obvious about Dave. :nod:

[Joe1240]

He is one of the best players of all-time in tennis. Not as great as Pete Sampras

[J.J.]

No. Everything he knows about tennis he's learnt from the books. He's like a robot, in difficult situations he can't improvise. When he finds someone against whom he cannot play his own game (see Nadal), he doesn't know what changes to apply to keep up with them.

[tralala]

does someone knows what mariahism is? pm me for an:sunny: swers and ill kiss you

[Kaos-girl]

Even thou I never really post here, I LOVE tennis. And today, Nadal proved Federer is not invincible. It was an amazing match, and I'm glad Nadal won. He deserved it.

And I agree with J.J. Federer doesn't know how to improvise.

[J.J.]

I think Federer wouldn't even have made it to the final if Safin had had a different mindset for the semifinal match. He can play much better than the swiss when he wants to. Too bad he is so inconstant and has the shortest attention span I've ever seen. lol

[gameboy]

I don't watch many of Federer's matches, because I always say he bores me. He has since he started to win all the time. I mean, he has some great matches, but I'm bored of him. I'm not much of a Nadal fan either, but lately Mens' tennis has bored me.
Although I'm watching Wimbledon right now, on ESPN classics since my dvr cut it off yesterday, pretty good match.

[pranksternicky]

No. Everything he knows about tennis he's learnt from the books. He's like a robot, in difficult situations he can't improvise. When he finds someone against whom he cannot play his own game (see Nadal), he doesn't know what changes to apply to keep up with them.

thats not true at all!

[pranksternicky]

I think Federer wouldn't even have made it to the final if Safin had had a different mindset for the semifinal match. He can play much better than the swiss when he wants to. Too bad he is so inconstant and has the shortest attention span I've ever seen. lol

I dont believe that either, I think Federer would have still smashed him even if he was trying.

[pranksternicky]

Not today, he isn't.

And you're stating the obvious about Dave. :nod:

lol aint that the truth

[J.J.]

pranksternicky if you can't accept what other people think on the subject, why did you ask for opinions at all?! lol

[pranksternicky]

pranksternicky if you can't accept what other people think on the subject, why did you ask for opinions at all?! lol

I can accept other people's opinions. Doesnt mean I have to agree with them..