What are you Britney fans' opinions on Miley Cyrus?

[John]

Thank you.




No poll, but select of the following:

- great singer, great performer, great actress
- mediocre at best
- could be the next Britney if she tried
- too slutty
- too not talented; she can't sing worth a damn
- who?
- go away, hater

[Lady T]

who? lol and im not actually jokin, who is she?

[tiger_rascal]

She would be nobody without her father.

Next. :arrow:

[dirrrty]

Take away her show and she has nothing

[Cubasterd]

I think she's just a kid who has a show on the Disney Channel.... and she's pretty hott too. lol

Post-Disney, I don't see her being bigger than Hilary Duff

[WRmasque]

^yeah i agree
hilary duff was once in the same position with lizzie macguire

[britspearsrules]

I like her song on the radio right now, but its not near as big as britneys first song on the radio :D Shes cute, but wouldnt be anywhere without her father.

[Lucky_19]

Her song on the radio is ok. I don't really know much about her, but her face annoys me. Shes not a cute girl.

[creamforbritney]

I think she would make a great sacrifice for harvest.

[Beutifulstranger]

Mileys personality is annoying... and the only song i know of hers is best of both worlds.

[Danster]

who? lol and im not actually jokin, who is she?
http://photos-132.ll.facebook.com/photos-ll-sctm/v200/78/64/1561590132/n1561590132_30054651_2643.jpg

[ÄLAJYN]

I think she's just a kid who has a show on the Disney Channel.... and she's pretty hott too. lol

Post-Disney, I don't see her being bigger than Hilary Duff


Well shes WAY bigger than Hilary was when she was on Disney. Her tour grossed 68million at the boxoffice. Her show has higher ratings, shes got 2 triple platinum albums, and 4 on billboard, she gots WIGS out. Hannah is raking in plenty of money for herself and disney. Hilary hasnt had a hit movie since what...the lizzie mcguire movie? All she has is like what... a clothing line or something? which barely brings her lik 12 mill a year(sure its alot but noone really cares for her anymore)

[Blueskies511]

I cannot stand her, she's not even talented

[heavenwaits_22]

Don't like her, don't listen to her. I think she's annoying.

[aleronihead]

Miley now = Britney in 98/99.

[jimmyboy]

Miley now = Britney in 98/99.
In the USA only, perhaps. She is nowhere near Britney's status... Not even Mandy's status.

[heavenwaits_22]

Miley now = Britney in 98/99.Hardly. Please don't put them in the same sentence again.

Miley is a local star. Britney was immediately known all over the world. Plus she's still a worldwide star. Miley is hardly known here in Canada, and abroad.

[~Crybaby~]

Whatever, she'll never compare to Hilary Duff. :o

[ÄLAJYN]

In the USA only, perhaps. She is nowhere near Britney's status... Not even Mandy's status.


mandy is nobody, in every country

[Lady T]

^^ lol i think she is doing quite well

i googled her and i know who she is now, and i don't have no love for her, she is no way like britney or antyhin slightly close! she is someone who got lucky coz of her dad, who btw i had to google as well as they arent really well known over here lol

[aleronihead]

Hardly. Please don't put them in the same sentence again.

Miley is a local star. Britney was immediately known all over the world. Plus she's still a worldwide star. Miley is hardly known here in Canada, and abroad.
Oh hey there, it's called an opinion, and I hold to it. Please don't presume to tell me my opinion.

And I'm speaking from an American POV, what with me being American and not knowing what other countries think of either artist.

[heavenwaits_22]

Oh hey there, it's called an opinion, and I hold to it. Please don't presume to tell me my opinion.

And I'm speaking from an American POV, what with me being American and not knowing what other countries think of either artist.I'm not telling you to change your opinion. lol I'm saying please don't compare them since they really have nothing in common other than they used to be on a kid friendly show, and had millions of little kids as fans. Miley is not going to be remembered, nor is she popular worldwide from the get-go. Britney is going to be remembered, and she was an instant star worldwide. It's practically common knowledge for pop music fans.

[aleronihead]

I'm not telling you to change your opinion. lol I'm saying please don't compare them since they really have nothing in common other than they used to be on a kid friendly show, and had millions of little kids as fans. Miley is not going to be remembered, nor is she popular worldwide from the get-go. Britney is going to be remembered, and she was an instant star worldwide. It's practically common knowledge for pop music fans.
Did you miss the point of the thread? The thread is ASKING for comparisons and peoples' opinions.

She's a teen star bread by Disney who has all the hype in the world and courts the flirtation of sexuality. She = Britney when Britney first came out, imo.

[ÄLAJYN]

I dont see a problem with Miley besides her speech. shes no Erykah Badu, but atleast she writes her own albums and works really hard. why people hate the bitch is beyond me

[heavenwaits_22]

Did you miss the point of the thread? The thread is ASKING for comparisons and peoples' opinions.

She's a teen star bread by Disney who has all the hype in the world and courts the flirtation of sexuality. She = Britney when Britney first came out, imo.It's hardly asking for comparisons. It's just asking for opinions.

[aleronihead]

It's hardly asking for comparisons. It's just asking for opinions.
Well my opinion would be that Miley today is what Britney was in 1998 in the US.

[heavenwaits_22]

Well my opinion would be that Miley today is what Britney was in 1998 in the US.That's nice. But I disagree.

[ThoughtIKnewYou]

http://photos-132.ll.facebook.com/photos-ll-sctm/v200/78/64/1561590132/n1561590132_30054651_2643.jpg

Eww is that photoshopped spunk on her face? :roll:

Still....its pretty disturbing that someone would take the time to photoshop semen on the face of a 15 year old. :noway: welcome to 2008, people

and IMO....Miley's parents will eagerly ride their daughter's coattails to fame. If she continues, she may be Britney 2.0 based upon her immense popularity with the kiddie sect and (as Ali said) her unabashed flirtation with sexuality at a young age

[heavenwaits_22]

Some people in the media need to stop calling her Britney. She will never be anywhere near as great as Britney was/is.

Any who, I think that picture is real. I think someone said it was ice-cream. Although it looks a little clumpy to me rofl.

[dsimplestar]

who is mandy lol?

[ThoughtIKnewYou]

Some people in the media need to stop calling her Britney. She will never be anywhere near as great as Britney was/is.

Any who, I think that picture is real. I think someone said it was ice-cream. Although it looks a little clumpy to me rofl.

no way that is ice cream. that looks EXACTLY like some dude just supersoaked her! :laugh:

[heavenwaits_22]

no way that is ice cream. that looks EXACTLY like some dude just supersoaked her! :laugh:Well I'm only stating what I heard. Someone who I saw posted the picture said it was ice-cream. I didn't say it.

[Danster]

Popularity
Britney>>>>>>>Miley

Beauty
Britney>>>>>>>Miley

Singing talent
Britney = Miley

Lip Synching skills
Britney = Miley

[Elroy Jetson]

Miley now = Britney in 98/99.

Actually... I don't think Miley is too bad, I'll even say that she has the potential to become a huge legitimate pop star like Britney, but as of right now, she's still quite the novelty act.

She's already sexing up her image and creating controversy without even releasing an actual first single. "See You Again" was part of a Hannah Montana compilation... not a Miley album. That being said, she's taking her career towards an awkward path... I wouldn't call her the next Britney (as many are) but the next Molly Ringwald or Lindsay Lohan seems most appropriate.

[aleronihead]

I don't think people realized that I specified Miley = Britney in 98/99. Meaning, when Britney, too, was a teen novelty act backed by Disney with just a little bit of controversy.

[Cubasterd]

I don't think people realized that I specified Miley = Britney in 98/99. Meaning, when Britney, too, was a teen novelty act backed by Disney with just a little bit of controversy.

You're wrong though.
Britney was a new artist with a #1 single whose Disney backing was more of a way to draw in additional record sales. Britney burst out with 'baby one more time' and that song alone appealed to everyone (adults included). Then it was her dancing which got the respect from dancers and sexuality that drew in the headlines. Britney was Britney Spears when she first released her first single and its been that way since.

[Ebi]

Miley pretty much is Disney and shes not worldwide. I don't see the comparison.

[aleronihead]

You're wrong though.
Britney was a new artist with a #1 single whose Disney backing was more of a way to draw in additional record sales. Britney burst out with 'baby one more time' and that song alone appealed to everyone (adults included). Then it was her dancing which got the respect from dancers and sexuality that drew in the headlines. Britney was Britney Spears when she first released her first single and its been that way since.
You're telling me adults don't enjoy See You Again?

Just because I think they have a lot of similarities doesn't mean I said CLONE. My god, defense mechanisms go up the second someone doesn't kiss ass.

Cue the "you defend your idol" crap. Which is crap because I don't have an idol, and I reserve the right to criticize or comment on anyone I am a fan of.

[lonely3]

Miley's not cute enough to be the next Britney. Sad, but true.

[Bruno Aguilera]

who? lol and im not actually jokin, who is she?
Same here :sunny: