~**Vocally**~ Christina vs Beyonce

[Sam♀]

Be fair, don't think of just power. Watch the video first then compare.

Both ladies are :love: what do you think their strengths are?
:)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9AlfAVjC750

[kristina]

You like Christina again? :)

And I think Beyonce hits high notes 10x better, but Christina's tone is richer.

[Sam♀]

I like christina's music


*typo :angel:

[Sam♀]

**dp

[julie.]

I prefer Christina.

[Ebi]

Beyonce is easier on the ears.

[Manuel]

I love both beyonce is getting better and better tho,but I choose Christina.

[HighHeeledHO]

Obviously Christina :laugh:
I love Beyonce's tone sometimes, but often she's flat.

[Blutina]

Beyonce's is cool but I prefer Christina's.

[Erizo]

Beyoncé can sing, but personally I prefer Christina, too.

[LoveChristinaB2B]

Beyonce is easier on the ears.


:laugh: @ Beyonce being easier on the ears that's because she barely sings HARD SONGS VOCALLY unlike Christina. It also has to do with Christina's TYPE of voice not to say that it's bad! :nod:

[LoveChristinaB2B]

Anyways I PICK CHRISTINA obviously even though Beyonce has a better sounding TONE!!!!

[Slayer4Xtina]

**dp

Double penetration? :confused:

[Sam♀]

Double penetration? :confused:
:funny: and ruin my tight V? I'll pass

[Tchelo]

Christina.

[Slayer4Xtina]

:funny: and ruin my tight V? I'll pass


http://i32.tinypic.com/2w3tbhd.gif

[Sam♀]

http://i32.tinypic.com/2w3tbhd.gif
is that a real girl

[DRashadRussell]

What's so interesting about this video is that the notes being compared between the two don't sound anything alike. They might be hitting the same "high" note but Beyonce never sounds like she's singing that high. What I've always liked about Christina is live she never sounds exactly like her recording (it's always worse, better, changed, etc) but Beyonce because of her tone usually sounds exactly the same and always makes it twice as hard to know if she's singing live

[Sam♀]

Not sure about it being live, I'm sure the person who made the video can answer your question ie kristina

[~Crybaby~]

What's so interesting about this video is that the notes being compared between the two don't sound anything alike. They might be hitting the same "high" note but Beyonce never sounds like she's singing that high. What I've always liked about Christina is live she never sounds exactly like her recording (it's always worse, better, changed, etc) but Beyonce because of her tone usually sounds exactly the same and always makes it twice as hard to know if she's singing live

ROTF! :roll:

Beyonce changes up the arrangements on her songs often, especially on tour and puts 10x more into her her live performances. She goes above and beyond what the studio version gives which is why she's one of the only people I'd rather hear live than studio.

The only reason why her vocals are questioned live is because they often sound so smooth that they can be studio vocals.

Her riffs, runs, high notes, tone are so clean. My only problem with her though is that sometimes (most noticeable on "Listen") her performances are so uninspired and don't move me. On that level, I prefer Christina. On a technical level though, she is absolute perfection and continues to get better every year.

[kristina]

ROTF! :roll:

Beyonce changes up the arrangements on her songs often, especially on tour and puts 10x more into her her live performances. She goes above and beyond what the studio version gives which is why she's one of the only people I'd rather hear live than studio.

The only reason why her vocals are questioned live is because they often sound so smooth that they can be studio vocals.

Her riffs, runs, high notes, tone are so clean. My only problem with her though is that sometimes (most noticeable on "Listen") her performances are so uninspired and don't move me. On that level, I prefer Christina. On a technical level though, she is absolute perfection and continues to get better every year.
obviously.

her studio vocals are weak (with the exception of a few). so much so, that even your girl hilary duff could sing 'em. the only studio vocal that would be on christina's level, would be listen, and bey hasn't proved to handle that one really well.

if beyoncé didn't make her vocals live 10x better, than i'd be worried.

[~Crybaby~]

obviously.

her studio vocals are weak (with the exception of a few). so much so, that even your girl hilary duff could sing 'em. the only studio vocal that would be on christina's level, would be listen, and bey hasn't proved to handle that one really well.

if beyoncé didn't make her vocals live 10x better, than i'd be worried.

Hilary Duff? Riiiigggght. You keep tellin' yourself that. What a mess. :hah:

[Reini]

Gawd. Everyone knows who´s on top!

[southatx2005]

:D Christina